Judge bars EPA from enforcing Civil Rights Act provision in Louisiana’s ‘Cancer Alley’

A federal judge on Tuesday night blocked the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) from enforcing Title VI of the Civil Rights Act’s disparate-impact requirements against Louisiana agencies.

Judge James D. Cain, a Trump appointee, ruled against residents of a stretch of parishes along the Mississippi River known as “Cancer Alley,” an epicenter of petrochemical manufacturing in the U.S. with disproportionately high rates of cancer.

Last year, Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry (R), then the state attorney general, sued the EPA to block a civil rights investigation into potential disparate impacts in the largely Black area of the state, arguing the probe exceeded statutory authority. The agency closed three civil rights complaints weeks later, but in his Tuesday ruling, Cain said existing regulations also constitute federal overreach. In the preliminary injunction, he wrote that the EPA and DOJ are barred from “imposing or enforcing any disparate impact based requirements against the State of Louisiana or any State agency under Title VI.”

Cain wrote that “pollution does not discriminate” and that “if a decision maker has to consider race, to decide [on enforcement] it has indeed participated in racism.”

Cain’s ruling comes the same day as a report from the National Minority Quality Forum, which found that 56 percent of communities of color are sited within 3 kilometers of a site producing carcinogenic waste. The town of Reserve in St. John the Baptist Parish has cancer risks about 50 times the national average.

Earthjustice, which filed the original Title VI complaint on behalf of St. John the Baptist Parish residents in 2022, blasted the ruling in a statement.

“The court’s decision to issue this injunction is bad enough, but what’s worse is that instead of fixing the discriminatory permitting programs that have created sacrifice zones like Cancer Alley, Louisiana is fighting tooth and nail to keep them in place,” said Sam Sankar, Earthjustice’s senior vice president of programs. “The public health crisis in St. John the Baptist Parish shows us why we need Title VI: EPA needs to be able to use our civil rights laws to stop states from running permitting programs that perpetuate environmental injustice.”

Written by ZACK BUDRYK

View the article by The Hill: https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/4427465-judge-bars-epa-from-enforcing-civil-rights-act-provision-in-louisianas-cancer-alley/

PRISM / Lily Levine

Judge bars EPA from enforcing Civil Rights Act provision in Louisiana’s ‘Cancer Alley’

Related posts

People of color face disproportionately higher risk of cancer from environmental toxins, new study finds

2024 Cancer Care Equity Summit: Speaker Presentations

Report shed lights on medically underserved cancer care as communities aim for improvement

We’ve forgotten pandemic prep

Cancer Initiative to Bring Resources to 10 Majority-Minority Communities

Flint congressman, mayor join in announcement on disparities in cancer care

How Can Cancer Risk Be Cut in Communities Exposed to Toxins?

Minority communities face higher environmental risks for cancer: Report

EPA to start testing for toxic chemicals in Fifth Ward this summer, as residents hold summit on ‘cancer cluster’

City of Houston approves $5 million to help residents voluntarily move out of 'cancer clusters'

EPA testing groundwater for possible link between contamination and cancer clusters

Houston’s Greater Fifth Ward is in a cancer cluster. Why don’t all the new residents know?

NMQF Connect: 2023 H-Town Health Fair

National Minority Quality Forum Is Hosting A Free Cancer Screening & Health Fair For Houston & Surrounding Areas

National Minority Quality Forum and the CEO Roundtable on Cancer Collaborate on Cancer Stage Shifting Initiative

The Charles McKinley Reynolds Jr. Pancreatic Cancer Pain Management Initiative

Recap: SurviveHer Pink Party on the Plaza in Harlem

CSSI on the Road: Empowering Communities with Multi-Cancer Detection Awareness

NMQF Connect: H-Town Health Fair

National Minority Quality Forum awarded $500,000 grant to conduct cancer research in Flint

Breast Cancer Awareness Month: Empowerment Through Knowledge

Cancer in the Asian Community: Cancer Disparities

Cancer in the Black Community: What are the Costs?

Cancer in the Black Community: Cancer Disparities

National Minority Quality Forum’s Cancer Stage Shifting Initiative Convenes ‘Cancer in Minority Communities’ White House Briefing

U.S. Preventive Services Task Force Issues New Breast Cancer Screening Recommendations

National Minority Quality Forum’s Adjoa Kyerematen Joins American Cancer Society National Breast Cancer Roundtable

United in Blue Rally Raises Awareness for Colorectal Cancer in Washington, D.C

US sues chemical company over cancer risk to minority area

Researchers, activists kick off effort to evaluate cancer incidence, link to Flint water crisis

Cancer Stage Shifting Initiative Announces Scientific Advisory Board Members

The White House Proclaims March 2023 National Colorectal Cancer Awareness Month

Why is colorectal cancer rising and what does it mean for Black, Brown communities?

National Minority Quality Forum and Exact Sciences’ Cancer Stage Shifting Initiative Leads Cancer Moonshot Initiative to Increase Cancer Screening in Flint

NMQF’s Kristen Hobbs Joins Mary J. Blige, Cancer Survivors, Advocates at American Cancer Society Roundtable on Breast Cancer

National Minority Quality Forum’s Cancer Stage Shifting Initiative Launches Website Exploring the Future of Multi-Cancer Early Detection & Equitable Cancer Care

National Minority Quality Forum Launches Alliance for Representative Clinical Trials to Reduce Healthcare Disparities in Underserved Populations

Texas: A Cancer-Plagued State

Trash From All Over the Country Winds Up in Uniontown

Could a spike in cancer cases in the Flint area be linked to the water crisis?

‘A much-needed step’: EPA creates a new environmental justice office

Welcome to 'cancer alley,' where toxic air is about to get worse

CONTACT US